Remote Work in Pakistan: Success or Struggle?

Remote work is a flexible work setup that permits employees to carry out their job responsibilities outside the office I.e. from home or any other location, hence; commonly known as telecommuting or working from home (WFH). Before COVID-19, remote work was relatively uncommon in Pakistan and often considered a perk rather than a mainstream option. Most employees were habituated to working from the office and only a small percentage engaged in telecommuting arrangements. However, the COVID pandemic forced a rapid and widespread shift towards remote work because of lockdown and social distancing measures.

During the peak pandemic period, Pakistan’s employment dropped from 55.7 million to 35 million, though gradually recovered to 52.5 million as the restrictions were uplifted. Sindh faced a major employment drop along with Punjab and Balochistan.About 6.7 million workers got reduced incomes which affected about 27.3 million people. The construction sector was hit the hardest; 59% of workers were jobless and 21% had faced a reduction in earnings. Informal sector workers were the most vulnerable, constituting 74% of the affected.

By mid-2020, 33% of the population was re-employed, but 53% of households reported income losses. Khyber Pakhtunkhwa experienced the highest income drop, especially in urban areas. Food insecurity was more severe in cities (13%) than in rural areas (8%). The poorest households faced the greatest financial strain. To adapt, many organizations shifted to remote work during the lockdown period.  This transition was not just a necessity but also highlighted several key benefits of remote work.

Primarily, there are various advantages of remote work such as flexibility, productivity, cost savings for businesses and employees, and environmental benefits.  Studies have shown that remote workers often experience higher productivity levels compared to their office-based counterparts. For instance, a study by Stanford University found that remote workers were 13% more productive than those working in traditional office settings. Additionally, it also provides employees with greater flexibility. This also enables employees to maintain work life balance that is necessary for their effective performance. 

Furthermore, Remote work can lead to substantial cost savings for both businesses and employees. Businesses can reduce costs associated with maintaining physical office spaces, such as rent, utilities, and office supplies. Simialry, employees can save on travel expenses and other work-related costs. According to Global Workplace Analytics, a typical employer can save about $11,000 per year for every employee who works remotely half of the time. 

Moreover, the environmental benefits of remote work are also significant. Reduced traveling leads to lower carbon emissions. A report by the International Energy Agency (IEA) estimated that increased remote work could reduce global CO2 emissions by 24 million tonnes annually, as well as there would be lower gasoline consumption. It could also reduce paper usage by shifting document handling to electronic systems. Additionally, it lowers electricity consumption by minimizing the need for office cooling, heating, and large-scale printing, thereby reducing the strain on power infrastructure.

It is important to note that remote work played a crucial role in mitigating job losses by allowing uninterrupted running of essential activities such as information processing, communication, and data coding. Even though tasks requiring physical presence could not be done remotely, many organizations managed by shifting to virtual environments. This adaptability helped businesses maintain operations and reduce employment disruptions. All this ultimately highlights remote work’s potential to support business continuity and resilience during crises. Despite the challenge in finding the right home-work balance and equipping employees for remote collaboration, the pandemic underscored remote work’s value in preserving jobs and operational stability.

In particular, the remote work situation in Pakistan has revealed both opportunities and challenges, highlighting how different regions have adapted to and benefited from this shift. However it would be erroneous to state the remote work only offers benefits. There are numerous challenges attached to this which need to be considered. While there is no doubt that remote work has provided flexibility and continuity for many businesses, it has also posed significant digital divides and infrastructural shortcomings. In many regions, limited access to reliable internet and technology impedes remote work feasibility. According to the World Bank, only 35% of Pakistan’s population has internet access. Many workers, especially in rural areas, struggle with unreliable internet access and power outages which is why their ability to work effectively from home has been affected significantly. Additionally, the shift to remote work has worsened gender inequalities due to which women bear a disproportionate burden of unpaid care work. 

These challenges are particularly obvious in Pakistan, where a lack of facilities, an increased poverty ratio, and a poor socio-economic situation further complicate the ability to work remotely.. Legal and regulatory gaps in form of data privacy issues, cybersecurity, and workers’ rights further hinder remote work. Moreover, remote work can also blur the lines between personal and professional life which is evident from a Buffer survey that found 22% of remote workers to be struggling with unplugging after work. To address these challenges, linking the digital divide, updating employment laws, and implementing strategies to support employees’ well-being are essential. With the right investments in digital infrastructure and supportive policies, it could become a more viable and inclusive option for Pakistan’s workforce. 

In fact Recent surveys in Pakistan indicate a growing preference for remote work, driven by its flexibility. Many employees appreciate the ability to balance work with personal commitments, leading to increased productivity and job satisfaction. However, challenges such as inadequate infrastructure, organizational resistance, and cultural factors hinder widespread adoption. 

In essence, Pakistan could benefit from remote work, but the afore-mentioned issues need to be fixed. Cultural preferences for office work, poor internet, and old policies are big obstacles. Although remote work proved effective during the pandemic, many businesses are still slow to adopt it. Without better internet, incentives for remote work tools, and updated laws, remote work’s growth in Pakistan will be limited as a result reducing potential benefits.

Bibliography:

1. Remote work, [Gartner] <Definition of Remote Work – Gartner Information Technology Glossary> last accessed 23 August 2024
2. Over 20 Million People Became Jobless in Pakistan Due to COVID-19, [Pro Pakistani], June 10 2021 <https://propakistani.pk/2021/06/10/over-20-million-people-became-jobless-in-pakistan-due-to-covid-19/> last accessed 23 August 2024
3.  Laura Amico, The realities of remote work,[Harvard Business Review], 29 October 2021 <https://hbr.org/2021/10/the-realities-of-remote-work> Last accessed 23 August 2024
4.  Remote Work Productivity Studies (2023) | RemoteJobs.org
5.  Susan Lund, What’s next for remote work?, [McKinsey Global Institute], 23 November 2020 <https://www.mckinsey.com/featured-insights/future-of-work/whats-next-for-remote-work-an-analysis-of-2000-tasks-800-jobs-and-nine-countries> Last accessed 23 August 2024
6.  Kate Lister, Working from Home: Unraveling the Employment Law Implications of the Remote Office, [Journal of Labour and Employement], July 2022 <https://www.americanbar.org/content/dam/aba/publications/aba_journal_of_labor_employment_law/v36/no-2/working-from-home-unraveling-the-employment-law-implications-of-the-remote-office.pdf>Last accessed 24 August 2024
7.  Work from home experience, [Global Workplace Analytics]<https://globalworkplaceanalytics.com/global-work-from-home-experience-survey> Last accessed 23 August 2024
8.  Daniel crow, Working from home can save energy and reduce emissions. But how much? 12 June 2020<https://www.iea.org/commentaries/working-from-home-can-save-energy-and-reduce-emissions-but-how-much> Last accessed 23 August 2024
9.  Addressing Climate Change Through a Remote Work Approach in Pakistan,[Aware Pakistan], 20 August 2023<https://awarepakistan.com/blog/104323/addressing-climate-change-through-a-remote-work-approach-in-pakistan/> Last accessed 24 August 2024
10.  Mehreen zahra, The coronavirus effect on Pakistan’s digital divide, [BBC], 14 July 2020<https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20200713-the-coronavirus-effect-on-pakistans-digital-divide> Last accessed 24 August 2024
11.  Tanima Ahmad, impacts of covid-19 on labor markets and household well-being in pakistan, [South Asia Gender Innovation Lab], Feburary 2021<https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/366361617082088695/pdf/Impacts-of-COVID-19-on-Labor-Markets-and-Household-Well-Being-in-Pakistan-Evidence-From-an-Online-Job-Platform.pdf>Last accessed 24 August 2024
12.  Rafique, Disruptions Caused in Pakistan by the COVID-19 Pandemic and Their Wireless Technology Based Solutions. [Wireless Pers Commun], 2024 < https://doi.org/10.1007/s11277-024-11327-5> Last accessed 24 August 2024
13.  WFH One Year Later: 43 Statistics on The Remote Work Experience & Plans to Return to the Office,7 April 2021 <https://www.industryselect.com/blog/statistics-on-the-remote-work-experience#:~:text=And%20when%20asked%20in%20this%20Buffer%20survey%20to,%E2%80%A2%201%200%25%20pointed%20to%20distractions%20at%20home.> Last accessed 24 August 2024
14.  Javeria Shoukat, Remote working trend in Pakistan, 3 May 2023 <https://medium.com/@javeriashoukat297/remote-working-trend-in-pakistan-fa23722fa12b> Last accessed 24 August 2024
15.  Katherine Haan,Remote Work Statistics & Trends, [Forbes Advisor], 12 June 2023 < https://www.forbes.com/advisor/business/remote-work-statistics/> Last accessed 24 August 2024
16.  Insights into employee preferences for remote work <https://workforceremote.org/insights-remote-work-preferences/> Last accessed 24 August 2024
17.  Dr Javed Miraj, Assessment of remote work in Pakistan: Factors Contributing to Pakistan’s Lag in Remote Work Adoption, [Journal of Xi’an Shiyou University, Natural Science Edition], January 2024 <https://www.xisdxjxsu.asia/V20I01-70.pdf> Last accessed 24 August 2024Author: Ms. Mishaal Amjad (Mishaal Amjad is currently a 2nd Year LLB (Hons.), University of London at Pakistan College of Law. She has been the Correspondent of LEAP from 2023/24.)